Facts on Chiang Mai in Black while Disneyization spotted would be in Grey
Monday, December 6, 2010
Introduction to Chiang Mai
This is what globalisation brings about, every place becomes of a higher quality and places only strive to become top notch tourism destinations.
Saturday, December 4, 2010
Culture of Chiang Mai
The culture of Chiang Mai was originally mixed from that of Mon traders and Lanna Tai. The culture of Chiang Mai today encompasses many different aspects due to the many people migrating to Chiang Mai. For example, the Burmese migrating to Chiang Mai in the 16th century. Then follwed by the Chinese and Muslims in the later half of the 19th century 300+ years later after the Burmese arrived.
Although Chiang Mai is part of Thailand, it is safe to say that the culture of Chiang Mai is very distinctive from the whole of Thailand. Due to Chiang Mai's culture being influenced by the Lanna Tai which is a unique culture in itself.
Friday, December 3, 2010
Traditions of Chiang Mai
Food at Chiang Mai is an indigenous tradition that has been enriched by Arab, Indian, Malay and Chinese influence. Despite being infused with the cooking styles of other cultures, people of Chiang Mai love simple plain rice as it is the main staple for them. They would feel that they have not eaten if they did not eat rice. They even have various food dishes like desserts made out of rice. Like the sweet sticky rice with mango below.
They love also spicy food which is similar to the Thais in Thailand.
At the table the bulk of a meal consists of rice, which Thais flavor by taking small helpings from the central dishes. They use central serving spoons to serve the small portions onto their own plates, from which they eat. Serving themselves from one dish at a time, Thais usually finish each small portion before returning to a different dish for another; thus the full flavor of each dish may be savored in an equable atmosphere. In times of past hardships, this natural manner of sharing food also allowed a small amount of spicy flavoring to go a long way with plain rice.
Disneyization is seen here when the Lanna Tai culture is infused with the culture of other countries. It brings about a global similarity yet distinct in their own way. For example, the style of cooking becomes special when there is a mix.
However to cater to the tourists, Chiang Mai food is sold at food stalls near the Night Bazaar and Sompet Market. These two markets have English menus and there is dedifferentiation of consumption seen here as while Chiang Mai is marketed as a tourist destination. The tourists also have to eat as it is essential for living and the prices of food sold at such markets are usually marked up. Tourists spend obsessively as these food and commodities are unusually seen in their own country.
Transportation
There are various forms of transportation such as rental cars, tuk tuks, trains, songthaew (passenger pick up vehicles for big groups), samlors (rickshaws), bus, bikes and motorbikes.
However getting around Chiang Mai won't be too easy a task as the roads are now congested due to more and more Tuk Tuk cars on the road. And taxis are scarce in Chiang Mai. Therefore a tuk tuk ride is essential for really experiencing Thailand and Chiang Mai, which also a part of this theming.
This differentiates transportation in Thailand/Chiang Mai from other countries or cities as the sides of the car are not enclosed like a rickshaw except that it is motorised, providing a different experience. It sets Thailand apart from other countries which has taxis for transportation.
References:
http://www.chiangmai1.com/chiang_mai/food_in_chiang_mai.shtml
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chiang_Mai_Province#Local_Food
Indigenous groups
There are six major hill tribes with subcategories and clans that further divide the groups of indigenous people. Each hill tribe has its own customs, language, dressing, skills, craft and spiritual belief and this applies to even subcategories within each hill tribe. For example, they have their own dialects even within one hill tribe and dress differently.
I will only touch on certain hill tribes that largely have to do with disneyization and their way of life and such. All the hill tribes come into contact with foreign cultures as they are more than happy to receive tourists as it means that there is money to made. Money making opportunities are welcomed as the hill tribes are rural and most of them are poor.
Karen
The largest minority group in Chiang Mai is the Karen. Some of the tribes are still practicing animism or being buddhist while many of the Karen were converted to Christianity by the missionaries.
They wore woven V-neck tunics of a range of natural colours and turbans. Unmarried women would wear long white V-neck tunics to distinct themselves from the rest. They occupy lowland areas and engage in agriculture. However they are the most environmentally conscious of the hill tribes as they practice crop rotation.
Padaung
The Paduang are part of the Karen people but they escaped and started a different hill tribe on their own.
The Padaung attract many curious visitors on account of their long-necked women. The women had to wear neck rings so that they would resemble their ancestors which are dragons and swans. Long necks symbolised elegance and sexuality. It was also hypothesised that it prevented them from being slaves to other tribes as the women appeared less attractive to other tribes.
Where does Disneyization come in?
Disneyization occurs here when most of the Karen, which is the majority of the hill tribes, were converted to a religion that was of something new to them. This is known as theming as the world is becoming more similar in the sense of religion. Christianity brought about antagonisation at the start because Christian missionaries promote and decry other religions like Buddhist and animism. They said stuff like Christians would go the heaven while people from other religion would burn in hell. Another hill tribe which is the Akha also goes through the same process till majority of the people converted to Christianity. People of these tribes feel that Christianity has diluted their original culture and religion.
A tradition of beautifying women by adding brass rings, up to 5 kilogrammes, to their necks has been preserved largely for generating tourism. Although the neck appears cruelly elongated, it is the collarbone which has been displaced rather than the stretching and weakening of the neck.
The culture of the women having to wear neck rings were almost disneyified under theming as the government of Thailand wants Chiang Mai to be more modernised. So that Thailand will be more in sync with the 20th century world. The government did not allow the younger women to wear the neck rings if they wanted to continue with education. However, some of the young girls continued with their tradition as they knew it was a source of revenue.
Also, the women of Padaung were subjected to emotional labour as they had to pretend that they were happy with being stared at and photographed by tourists. They had to wear the neck rings for tradition and not to generate more revenue for themselves but the hill tribes are run by local businessmen and these people also want to earn from their tradition. They knew that their culture has been exploited due to the surge of tourism and feel antagonised. In actual fact, most of them suffer while wearing the neck rings. For example, their necks are burnt or bruised by the neck rings that are welded on. They are refugees and they are glad to even be alive. Therefore they had to accept tourism and smile to tourists despite feeling unhappy deep down inside as they are safe and can earn some money. Moreover, tourists would expect to get the same friendliness from the locals.
And moreover in comparison to Disney, while the idea of emotional labour may concern some Chiang Mai people, there is a certain similarity with Disney as Disney is not short of people who welcome this as part of their job and want to work at Disney. Similarly, there are people who want to preserve the culture because of their pride and don't mind earning money from it.
The way they dress
For example, some indigenous people and communities, dress in their traditional clothing only when the tourists are visiting them, even though they would only wear it for ceremonies and festivals when the tourists aren’t visiting. The false image that these indigenous cultures present to the tourist is misleading and does not give the tourist a true cultural experience. Like example, the Karen people is usually seen in their traditional clothes as they are a popular settlement to visit when tourists visit Chiang Mai.
References:
http://www.1stopchiangmai.com/culture/hill_tribes/
http://www.chiangmai1.com/chiang_mai/hill_tribes.shtml
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chiang_Mai_Province
http://www.chiangmainews.com/indepth/details.php?id=469
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kayan_Lahwi
http://www.google.com.sg/imglanding?q=hill+tribes+chiang+mai+houses&um=1&hl=en&tbs=isch:1&tbnid=kNL_V7tU4u83PM:&imgrefurl=http://www.ultimatejourney.com/Chap29.html&imgurl=http://www.ultimatejourney.com/T.BambooHuts.JPG&zoom=1&w=640&h=480&iact=hc&ei=TFL7TIPsCcbKrAfiu_TPCA&oei=TFL7TIPsCcbKrAfiu_TPCA&esq=1&page=1&tbnh=134&tbnw=179&start=0&ved=1t:429,r:21,s:0&biw=1408&bih=714
http://www.google.com.sg/imglanding?q=removal+of+neck+rings&um=1&hl=en&tbs=isch:1&tbnid=J8XHCnjoLTK0FM:&imgrefurl=http://forums.majorgeeks.com/showthread.php%253Ft%253D225359%2526page%253D2&imgurl=http://i271.photobucket.com/albums/jj147/leretserge/femme_girafe.jpg&zoom=1&w=400&h=600&iact=hc&ei=T1X7TN6ZMoa8cI_wlPQO&oei=I1X7TMLJHsLUrQf074DXCA&esq=4&page=3&tbnh=131&tbnw=86&start=64&ved=1t:429,r:2,s:64&biw=1408&bih=714
Thursday, December 2, 2010
Languages of Chiang Mai
Languages in Chiang Mai is disneyified due to English being more commonly used by the tourists and the people of Chiang Mai have to take up lessons to learn English instead of their own literature which sometimes do not have a written version.
Mode of Educations in Chiang Mai
Chiang Mai is home to five universities, Buddhist and Christian seminaries, technical colleges, four international English language schools and one German one, a large university teaching hospital and several private ones, some with nursing schools. There are also many private language schools as well as the AUA, the British Council, Australian and New Zealand centres and the Alliance Francaise.
The international schools cater for the children of ex-patriates living in Thailand and are increasingly attracting Thai children and those from neighbouring countries, whose parents want them to be educated in English. As if their children can speak English, they can communicate with the world more smoothly.
This occurs when the world becomes more globalised and English would be the common language between people.
People in Chiang Mai can learn not only in schools and universities but also by interacting with tourists. However, they hardly read or get to watch movies or documentaries. But there are certain forms of education like art exhibits in international schools that certain people of a limited age can . They are not given any choice and this is a huge disadvantage to them. The art exhibition below promotes foreign culture like Spiderman, and this would be of influence to the future generations as they would be more interested in something that is of fantasy and mystery.
References:
http://www.chiangmai-thai.com/education.htm
http://www.chiangmainews.com/ecmn/viewfa.php?id=2571
http://www.moe.go.th/English/
Leisure Programmes
Loi Kra-Thong
One of the most beautiful sights that is very enjoyable due to the movement of lights are the annual festival of Loi Kra-Thong held in November. This festival is to show gratitude to the water for the usage of the river.
As the moon rises in the evening, small lotus-shaped raft of banana leaves filled with flowers, candle, a snip of your nail, a piece of your hair, and a few coins, is set afloat in the ocean or down a waterway begging good luck for the forthcoming year. The best Kra-Thong must be made of banana leaves or bread so that it would become food for the fish and there would be less pollution. In Chiang Mai, there is releasing the large paper hot-air balloons. It is to symbolise casting away your troubles and calling in the hopes of the future.
Songkran
Traditionally it was celebrated by Buddha images being bathed with water and the showing of respect to monks and elders. From the sprinkling of water onto someone’s hands as a sign of respect it has evolved into mass drenching for anyone who decides to venture outdoors. Tourists are attracted to the wild side of Songkran instead of what it traditionally was. Everyone would go for thrill therefore the festival was slowly modified to suit the taste of the tourists.
Spas and Thai massages
Spas in the past were health resorts at natural waters or baths that could be taken by people suffering from rheumatism and kindred complaints, however in recent years, the Lanna tradition of massages and herbal therapies are integrated into spas to create something special.
Spas would often be coupled by Thai massages.
References:
http://www.chiangmai1.com/chiang_mai/festivals.shtml
http://www.openchiangmai.com/chiangmai_festival.php
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vpCSvi0n_6o
Wednesday, December 1, 2010
What is Chiang Mai famous for?
Chiang Mai is famous for being scenic with all the mountain ranges, valleys, flora and fauna. It is also popular because of the Lanna Tai's unique culture, locally made products and handicrafts.
However, today it is known for their Karen long neck settlement, Lanna Cultural Centre Night Bazaar, handicraft boutiques, Chiang Mai Night Safari which is modelled after Singapore's Night Safari, elephant rides, Khantoke Dinner, temples.
Khantoke Evenings
"Arguably the best way to enjoy Northern Thai culture is to spend an evening at a Khantoke dinner. Increasingly popular with tourists, these events have evolved into a superb display of the best of Thai culture; including a sumptuous spread of Northern Thai food (served in traditional-style at floor level), classical Thai dancing from exquisitely dressed dancers, and traditional Northern and other Thai music played on unique Asian instruments. Several of these venues are now situated out in the suburbs and take place in beautifully constructed traditional pavilions. Your hotel or guesthouse can organise this activity for you. There is also a free cultural show every evening at the Night Market." -quoted from http://www.1stopchiangmai.com/culture/festivals/
The whole experience has become very commercialised, just like Disney's themepark. From the extract above, we can see that the performance is not similar to what it traditionally was due to the word evolved.
There might be several performances occurring at the same time at different locations sometimes just next to each other while in the past, it was only performed to entertain businessmen at parties for VIPS. There is no more significance of the traditional dances performed as it becomes a daily ritual for the performers. Emotional labour is found here in the performances. Although they give their all in performing for the tourists, the authentic traditional feel is gone. When the performers give their all in performing, the tourist might feel that the performer is not actually working but taking pride in their tradition. Therefore, they are encouraged to spend more due to the smiling and helpful demeanour of the performers.
You can take photos with the performers after the performances or participate in the rituals for a small fee. This feels almost as if you are taking pictures with the mascots at Disney. And the tourists also would not understand the history of the dance or what story it has to tell as there is no such information given during the performance. The whole experience is packaged. For example, you go for the dinner but you feel compelled to participate in the photo taking or the rituals as it seems only natural to do so.
Watching a cultural Lanna Tai performance while eating your dinner is what makes the whole experience unique. This is constructed history, such as the performances. Like the performances each have their own story but it is infused together so that the tourists could feast their eyes on all kinds. And plus there is good service because it was meant to entertain VIPs in the past, therefore it makes it possible for the prices of the Khantoke dinner to constantly fetch a higher price. And there is unlimited refills of food therefore it will constantly attract tourists to take part in an Khantoke dinner as it is satisfying in all sense.
Night Bazaar
You basically go there and enjoy yourselves but you will inevitably buy countless of souvenirs while being at Chiang Mai. This is where disneyization comes in due to dedifferentiation of consumption. Firstly, these type of markets provides a site for selling local products related to the Lanna culture that has accumulated over the years. And sales from such local products actually makes up for most of the profits earned from tourists in Chiang Mai.
More and more hotels are built and handicraft boutiques are set up to cater to the surge of tourists. And there is only a fine line between really consuming culture tourism or buying the products linked to their culture. Markets as such are carefully designed to make tourists purchase their products. For example, you can purchase the neck rings for a few hundred bahts. And there is cross promotion of goods which are the experience of culture and the products of culture.
The experience of being at Chiang Mai used to be visiting the hill tribes and looking at their way of life. But now people go to Chiang Mai to watch commoditised festive dances or to buy their handicraft which they used to make for keepsakes. These tourists have the impression that they are visiting the local hill tribes and understanding their way of life. But what they do not know is that they are actually encouraged to buy the commodities.
Chiang Mai Night Safari
Chiang Mai's Night Safari is a government nature theme park which is built to promote Chiang Mai tourism regarding to the government's policy apart from arts, cultures, traditions, and the beauty of nature which are the main fascinating tourist attractions.
For example, the Chiang Mai Night Safari pollutes Chiang Mai's water sources and it brings about more construction as tourists always want top-notch attractions and facilities. But it was still constructed because Thailand's sports and tourism minister wanted to up their competitive edge. More construction such as the Night Safari's new playground, which is a musical fountain to entertain kids. Places that focus more on entertainment tend to exploit the locals and degrade the environment, making the experience less authentic. It is ironic that while promoting a natural experience, all the facilities are built with high quality materials and the Night Safari does not blend in with the natural environment. Also, the animals at the Night Safari are either trafficked from Kenya or Australia with reference to Ecoterra.
This is Disneyization as the experience is themed. It is built to rival Singapore's Night Safari and the actual Disneyland itself. The facade of the Night Safari is very high class and yet it has cultural elements such as the elephant or animals found in Chiang Mai.
References:
http://www.ecoterra.net/sites/background-info.htm
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XuVav8zPCQ4&feature=related